OEM vs Aftermarket Phone Screens: What Actually Changes

iPhone opened on the repair mat for a screen replacement
The quick answer

Original quality screens match the factory display. Soft OLED aftermarket screens come close for less money. Hard OLED screens are cheaper but less drop resistant. LCD screens fitted to OLED phones are the cheapest and the most noticeable downgrade.

  • Ask your repair shop which grade is in the quote.
  • On OLED phones, avoid LCD replacements if you will keep the phone long.
  • LCD phones like the iPhone 11 and XR are best served by a good LCD.
  • Price differences can be large, so compare the same grade.

The four kinds of replacement screen

Original quality

An original or original quality screen matches the factory display in colour, brightness, thickness and touch. It is the best choice for anyone keeping the phone for years.

Soft OLED

A flexible OLED panel built to fit like the original. Colours and blacks are close to factory and battery use is normal. On most OLED iPhones it is the best value.

Hard OLED

A rigid OLED panel. Picture quality is good, but it is less flexible and more likely to crack again in a drop.

LCD for an OLED phone

An LCD panel built to fit an OLED phone. It costs the least, but it is thicker, less bright, has greyer blacks and uses more battery because it needs a backlight.

Side by side comparison

Original qualitySoft OLEDHard OLEDLCD in OLED phone
Colour and contrastFactoryVery closeGoodNoticeably flatter
BrightnessFactoryCloseCloseLower
Thickness and fitFactoryCloseCloseSlightly thicker
Battery useNormalNormalNormalHigher
Drop resistanceFactoryGoodLowerGood
PriceHighestMiddleLowerLowest

Overall picture quality compared to factory

Original qualityBest
Soft OLEDVery good
Hard OLEDGood
LCD in OLED phoneBasic
Illustrative comparison based on panels we fit at the shop. Individual parts vary by supplier.

What about phones that came with LCD?

The iPhone 8, SE, XR and 11 shipped with LCD screens, as do many budget Android phones. On these, a good quality LCD replacement looks just like the original. There is no OLED to downgrade from.

How to choose the right screen

  • Keeping the phone two years or more? Original quality or soft OLED.
  • Selling or trading in soon? A soft OLED keeps it looking right for the next owner.
  • Older phone, tight budget? Hard OLED, or LCD if cost matters most.
  • Kid’s phone that gets dropped weekly? A more affordable grade plus a good case and screen protector.
TipAsk for the grade in writing. Two quotes for an iPhone screen can be $80 apart simply because one is LCD and the other is soft OLED.

Will my phone show a parts message?

On iPhone 11 and newer, iOS can show a message in Settings when a screen is not a genuine Apple part. The screen still works normally. True Tone can be kept on many models when the original screen’s data is transferred during the repair. We tell you what to expect for your model before you choose.

Quick answers

Is aftermarket the same as fake?

No. Aftermarket means not made by the phone maker. Quality ranges from very good to poor, which is why the grade matters.

Does a cheaper screen affect Face ID?

No. Face ID uses separate sensors. The screen grade does not change it.

Can I upgrade from an LCD replacement later?

Yes. We can fit a better screen at any time.

Do Samsung phones have the same grades?

Yes, Galaxy AMOLED screens also come in original and aftermarket grades.

Not sure which screen to pick?

We show you the grades for your model side by side and let you choose, with a lifetime warranty on the part and labour.

Need a hand?

Talk to a real technician.

Text a photo for a repair price, or book a free IT assessment for your business. Shop at 546 Boler Rd, London.

Keep reading

More guides.