Repair or Replace Your Phone? A Simple Decision Guide

Coral iPhone XR after a screen, battery and back glass repair
The quick answer

Repair your phone if it still receives software updates, the repair costs less than about half the price of a comparable phone, and you are otherwise happy with it. Replace it if updates have ended, several major parts are failing at once, or it no longer does what you need.

  • Software support is the deciding factor most people miss.
  • A new battery plus a screen often costs less than a year of payments on a new phone.
  • Keeping a phone longer is better for your wallet and the environment.
  • Get a repair quote before you shop for a new phone, it costs nothing.

The 50 percent rule

A simple test works for most people: if the repair costs less than half of what a comparable replacement would cost, and the phone is still supported, repair it. If it costs more, or support has ended, it is usually time to replace it.

SituationUsual answer
Cracked screen, phone otherwise fineRepair
Battery under 80 percentRepair, and it will feel faster
Screen and battery both wornRepair both in one visit
No longer gets OS updatesReplace
Logic board failure on an old phoneUsually replace
Water damage on a newer phoneAssess first, often repairable

Check how long your phone will get updates

Security updates matter more than most people think. A phone that no longer gets them becomes more exposed to attacks over time, and apps eventually stop supporting it.

Software support promised or typical for recent phones

Google Pixel 8 and newer7 years
Samsung Galaxy S24 and newer7 years
Recent iPhonesTypically 6+ years
Google and Samsung published update commitments for Pixel 8 and Galaxy S24 and newer. Apple does not publish a fixed policy, but recent iPhones have typically received about six or more years of iOS updates.
TipNot sure if your phone is still supported? Tell us the model and we will check the current status for you.

What repairs actually cost

These are our typical ranges, before HST. Compare them with the price of a new phone you would actually buy, not the cheapest one on the shelf.

RepairTypical price
iPhone screen$99 to $250
Galaxy screen$120 to $320
Battery$69 to $129
Charging port$79 to $149
Back glass$99 to $199

A screen and battery together on most iPhones still costs a fraction of a new one.

When replacing makes more sense

  • Updates have ended. The phone will only become less secure.
  • Several major parts are failing. Screen, battery, cameras and port all at once.
  • Storage is constantly full. Repairs cannot add storage.
  • The board is damaged. On older phones, board level water damage often costs more than the phone is worth.
  • It is too slow for your apps even with a new battery.

The environmental case for repair

Most of a phone’s environmental footprint comes from making it, not using it. Keeping a phone in use for an extra year or two is one of the simplest ways to cut electronic waste. When you do replace it, recycle the old one properly or pass it on.

Should you fix it before selling or trading in?

Trade in programs grade cracked screens and backs down hard. A cracked phone can lose a large share of its trade in value. If the repair costs less than the difference, fixing it first makes financial sense. Ask us for a quote and compare it with your trade in offers.

Decide in four steps

  1. Check updates. Is your model still supported?
  2. Get a repair quote. It is free and takes minutes by text.
  3. Price a comparable phone. The one you would actually buy.
  4. Compare. Under half the price and supported? Repair it.

Quick answers

Is it worth fixing a three year old iPhone?

Usually, yes. Most three year old iPhones still get updates, and a screen or battery brings them back to like new.

Is it worth fixing an old Samsung?

If it still gets updates and the repair is reasonable, yes. Newer Galaxy S models have long update promises.

Can you move my data to a new phone if I replace it?

Yes. We can help transfer your data.

What do I do with my old phone?

Recycle it properly, sell it or pass it on. We can wipe it securely first.

Not sure whether to fix it?

Text us your model and the problem. We will give you an honest answer and an exact price.

Need a hand?

Talk to a real technician.

Text a photo for a repair price, or book a free IT assessment for your business. Shop at 546 Boler Rd, London.

Keep reading

More guides.